In the video “3 Medicinal Plants I Regret Adding to my Garden,” Da, an organic gardener and herbalist from Maine, shares valuable insights on why certain medicinal plants may not be the best addition to your garden. Da dives into the issues encountered with Staghorn Sumac, Red Clover, and St. John’s Wort, explaining how their aggressive behaviors and potential hazards outweigh their benefits.
Through time-stamped segments, the video breaks down each plant’s allure and the challenges faced, such as the invasive root systems of Staghorn Sumac and Red Clover, and the toxicity of St. John’s Wort. Da’s personal experiences emphasize the importance of careful plant selection to avoid unforeseen difficulties and landscape issues.
Staghorn Sumac (Rhus typhina)
Initial Attraction
When you first encounter the Staghorn Sumac, it’s easy to fall in love with its unique and exotic appearance. The tree boasts a tropical look that’s quite unusual for a plant in the northern climates. Its feathery, palm-like leaves and beautiful red flower clusters can be quite a sight, especially when everything else around is just the usual green. Not to mention, its berries are not only edible but also possess medicinal properties. The idea of having a plant that offers both beauty and utility makes it an appealing addition to any garden.
Problematic Aggressive Growth
However, while the Staghorn Sumac might win you over with its initial charm, it doesn’t take long before you start noticing some serious drawbacks. Its root system is aggressively invasive. These roots can spread far and wide, making it exceedingly difficult to keep the plant contained. If you’re not vigilant, your garden may quickly become overrun with these unwanted guests, competing with your other plants for nutrients and space. Controlling this rampant growth can become a frustrating and time-consuming endeavor.
Damage to Foundations
The aggressive root system of the Staghorn Sumac is not just a nuisance in the garden; it can also cause significant structural problems. Those robust roots can penetrate and damage foundations, causing long-term maintenance challenges. You might find these persistent roots finding their way under porches, patios, or even through your home’s foundation, leading to costly repairs and an endless battle to keep the Sumac at bay.
Initial Attraction
Tropical Look
One of the primary reasons you might be drawn to the Staghorn Sumac is its striking, tropical appearance. Its large, lush leaves create a canopy that can provide a beautiful aesthetic in your yard. During the fall, the foliage turns vivid shades of red, orange, and purple, adding a splash of color to your garden.
Edible Berries
Another appealing aspect of this plant is its cluster of red berries. These berries have a tart, lemony flavor and can be used to make sumac lemonade, a delightful and refreshing drink. They also hold medicinal benefits, making the Staghorn Sumac a multipurpose plant.
Rapid Growth
If you’re looking for a plant that fills in space quickly, the Staghorn Sumac fits the bill. It can grow up to 6 feet in a single growing season, rapidly establishing itself and providing shade and shelter much sooner than many other trees.
Shade Provision
In addition to its rapid growth, the dense canopy of the Staghorn Sumac can provide much-needed shade, making it a perfect candidate for planting near patios or decks where you might want a reprieve from the summer sun.
This image is property of i.ytimg.com.
Problematic Aggressive Growth
Invasive Root System
While that fast growth can be a blessing, it comes at a cost. The Staghorn Sumac spreads through a highly invasive root system. These roots can extend far away from the trunk, sprouting new trees wherever they find an opportunity, leading to a garden overrun by sumacs if not constantly managed.
Difficult to Control
Controlling this invasive nature requires considerable effort and can become a regular chore. Constant monitoring, cutting back sprouts, and possibly using barriers to contain the roots are necessary steps to keep the plant from taking over your yard.
Competition with Native Plants
The aggressive root system doesn’t just take over space; it also competes fiercely with native plants for nutrients and water. This can lead to the decline of other plants you might prefer to cultivate, making the Staghorn Sumac a somewhat unfriendly neighbor.
Damage to Foundations
Potential Structural Damage
The Staghorn Sumac’s roots are not just limited to the garden; they can cause real structural damage. These pervasive roots can find their way under foundations, porches, and patios, causing cracks and other structural problems that can be both challenging and expensive to repair.
Root Penetration Issues
The roots’ ability to penetrate deep and spread wide poses a risk to your home’s structural integrity. This capability to infiltrate hard surfaces makes them a formidable opponent in maintaining a safe and sound structure around your home.
Long-term Maintenance Challenges
Once the roots have started causing damage, addressing these issues becomes a long-term challenge. Constant vigilance, repairs, and possibly professional intervention become necessary to manage the repercussions of planting such an aggressive species close to your home.
Red Clover
Medicinal Benefits
Red Clover, with its numerous medicinal benefits, can be a valuable addition to your herbal garden. It acts as a blood purifier, aids in improving skin health, and acts as a nitrogen fixer, enriching the soil. Clover is also excellent for attracting pollinators, which are beneficial for the overall health of your garden.
Unintended Spread
Despite its medicinal advantages, Red Clover’s propensity to spread can quickly become problematic. It spreads both through aggressive seed dispersion and its enthusiastic root spread, often competing with other plants in your garden.
Attraction of Deer
If you live in an area where deer are a common sight, planting Red Clover can become an open invitation for these animals. Deer are particularly attracted to Clover, and their feeding habits can lead to the destruction of not just the Clover but other plants in your garden as well.
Medicinal Benefits
Blood Purification
Red Clover is renowned for its blood-purifying properties. Herbalists often use it in tinctures and teas to cleanse the blood, promoting overall health and well-being. This makes it a valuable plant for those keen on herbal medicine.
Skin Health
In addition to its internal benefits, Red Clover is excellent for improving skin health. Its anti-inflammatory properties make it useful in treating a variety of skin conditions, from eczema to psoriasis, making it a sought-after plant for natural skincare remedies.
Nitrogen Fixation
One of Red Clover’s ecological benefits is its ability to fix nitrogen in the soil. This process enriches the soil, making it more fertile and supporting the growth of other plants. This characteristic alone can make Red Clover a beneficial plant to have around, especially in a garden focused on sustainability.
Pollinator Attraction
Red Clover is a favorite among pollinators such as bees and butterflies. This makes it a fantastic plant to cultivate if you’re looking to boost pollinator activity in your garden, which in turn supports the health and productivity of your entire plant ecosystem.
Unintended Spread
Aggressive Seed Dispersion
Red Clover has a knack for spreading its seeds far and wide. This aggressive dispersion can lead to Clover popping up in areas where you might not want it, requiring you to constantly manage its growth and keep it from overtaking other plants.
Invasive Root Spread
Alongside its seed dispersion, Red Clover’s roots can spread invasively. These roots can encroach on other garden areas, making it difficult to control and often leading to it overshadowing other, more delicate plants.
Competition with Other Plants
The spread of Red Clover can result in competition with other plants in your garden. Its robust growth and spread can hinder the development and health of neighboring plants, making it a challenging species to coexist with other flora in your carefully planned garden.
Attraction of Deer
Damage by Feeding
Deer are particularly fond of Red Clover, making it a frequent target in gardens where it’s planted. The damage caused by deer feeding can be extensive, often leaving your garden looking ragged and less productive.
Destruction of Plants
Once deer develop a taste for your Clover, they are likely to munch on other plants in your garden. This can result in significant destruction, not just to the Clover but to your entire garden space.
Increased Maintenance Needs
Dealing with the fallout from deer attraction means increased maintenance efforts. You’ll need to find ways to deter deer, repair the damage they cause, and manage the spread of the Clover, adding more work to your gardening routine.
St. John’s Wort (Hypericum perforatum)
Medicinal Benefits
St. John’s Wort is widely celebrated for its medicinal properties. It’s commonly used to treat depression and anxiety, making it a valuable plant in herbal medicine. Additionally, it has benefits for skin conditions and nerve pain, offering a broad range of healing applications.
Pest Attraction
Despite its medicinal benefits, St. John’s Wort is known for attracting certain pests, particularly the St. John’s Wort Beetle. This beetle can be quite destructive, leading to challenges in maintaining a healthy plant.
Toxicity Concerns
Another major concern with St. John’s Wort is its toxicity. The plant can be toxic to many animals, including livestock and pets, posing a risk if you have animals that might come into contact with it.
Conclusion
Balancing Benefits and Drawbacks
While Staghorn Sumac, Red Clover, and St. John’s Wort offer numerous benefits, they also come with significant drawbacks. The aggressive growth, potential for structural damage, attraction of pests, and toxicity all weigh heavily against their inclusion in a well-balanced garden.
Unsuitability for My Garden
Given these considerations, these three plants have proven unsuitable for my garden. The effort required to manage their drawbacks outweighs the benefits they bring, making them more trouble than they’re worth.
Look Forward to Upcoming Content
I hope you found this article insightful and helpful in making informed decisions about what to plant in your garden. Stay tuned for upcoming content where we will delve into the benefits of plantain and how to make plantain salves. Until then, happy gardening!